Live From the Courtroom

Son testifies that Michele Williams tried to frame another woman for husband's murder

Michele Williams' son testifies about plot to frame another woman

Accused murderer Michele Williams wiped away tears as photos of her husband’s dead body were shown in court during the first day of her Tarrant County trial. Michele, 45, is charged with murder and tampering with evidence in the 2011 shooting death of Greg Williams.

Prosecutors ran through a handful of witnesses after opening statements. Michele’s son, Andrew O’Brien, was stoic as he testified that his mother asked him to frame another woman for Greg’s murder.

Kathy Williams, Greg’s first wife, reportedly was the target of Michele’s plot.

  Kathy Williams, Greg’s first wife, reportedly was the target of Michele’s plot.

Andrew said that Michele asked him and his brother to help clean up the remains of Greg’s body from the couple’s Keller home. At one point, Michele pulled Andrew aside and asked him “to do something for her.”

“She asked me to call some friends and have them frame Kathy,” Andrew said. “I was in shock.”

According to Andrew, Michele gave him specific instructions to carry out, including buying an “extra large sweatshirt” and wearing it while he fired a pistol so that it would have gun power residue on it.

Then, she wanted someone to break into Kathy’s car in an inconspicuous way and plant the sweatshirt inside. Finally, Andrew was supposed to call 911 and tip them off to Kathy’s involvement.

“She was very calm when she asked me to do it,” Andrew said.

Although he never went through with the plot to frame Kathy, Andrew admitted he waited several months before telling the district attorney’s office about his mother’s wishes. “When you are asked that question by your own mother, it is really hard to know what to do,” the 26-year-old said.

After a week with no action from Andrew, Michele told him not to bother. “She told me since I wasn’t getting it taken care of, she was going to figure it out on her own,” he said.

In January 2013, Andrew finally reported his mother’s plot to the authorities.

“At that point, I felt as though Michele was going to put the blame on my brother,” Andrew said, adding that his brother, Lee O’Brien, had recently gotten into an argument with Michele.

“The next day, she asked me if I thought it was possible that Lee was the intruder [that killed Greg]. We had heard so many stories … that first year after Greg died was such a blur.”

Andrew said that Michele’s stories included variations on a home invasion and suicide. In at least one version of events, Michele told Andy that Greg had hit her in the face the night of the murder and given her a black eye. 

That’s the same theory prosecution floated in its opening statement. Michele now maintains that she hit herself in the face with a wrench to support the intruder theory.

At one point, Andrew said Michele asked him and Lee to take turns guarding the house because she was worried that someone would try to kill her.

“It was a roller coaster of emotions. Some days she’d be crying hard. Other days, she’d be laughing.”

--

New to the story? Catch up on the Michele Williams case here:

October 31, 2013: The making of the Keller black widow: Did Michele Williams get away with murder?

May 15, 2014: Accused murderess Michele Williams gets bond revoked amid fears she'd skip town

January 30, 2014: Keller black widow Michele Williams lands back in Tarrant County jail

February 10, 2014: Michele Williams rejects plea deal and opts for murder trial in husband's death

March 6, 2014: Keller black widow Michele Williams worked at strip club while out on bond

May 2, 2014: Peter Van Sant dishes on what made Michele Williams case so intriguing to 48 Hours

May 28, 2014: Couple offers to help post bond for accused murderer Michele Williams

 
Michele Williams mugshot
Michele Williams was indicted for murder in 2012. Photo courtesy of Keller Police Department
The Keller home of Greg and Michele Williams
The Keller home where Greg Williams was killed. Photo courtesy of Keller Police Department
Michele Williams and Greg Williams on their wedding day
Michele and Greg Williams on their wedding day in 2008. Photo courtesy of Keller Police Department
Michele Williams is accused of murdering her husband
Michele and Greg with family at their Keller home. Photo courtesy of 48 Hours