The Greatest Pirate Story Never Told is Off Broadway’s improvised, interactive, musical pirate adventure and was nominated as “Best Family Show of 2014” by the Off-Broadway Alliance Awards. Flung into the future by a musical-loving Sea Witch, a crew of misfit pirates-turned-actors must now perform the greatest pirate epic ever seen on stage. But when their script is partially obscured by a tragic squid ink accident, they turn to the audience to fill in the missing bits of the plot.