Michelle Yeoh in Everything Everywhere All at Once.
Photo courtesy of A24
The Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association (of which our own Alex Bentley is a member) has voted Everything Everywhere All at Onceas the best film of 2022, according to the results of its 29th annual critics’ poll released on December 19.
The mind-boggling and hilarious film, released in April, also garnered awards for Best Supporting Actor for Ke Huy Quan and Best Director for the team of Daniel Kwan and Daniel Scheinert.
The funny and solemn The Banshees of Inisherin was also well-represented in the critics' poll, winning for Best Actor for Colin Farrell, Best Supporting Actress for Kerry Condon, and Best Screenplay for Martin McDonagh.
Other awards included Best Actress to Cate Blanchett for her commanding turn in Tar; Japan's Decision to Leave for Best Foreign Language Film; Good Night Oppy for Best Documentary; Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio for Best Animated Film; Russell Carpenter, Avatar: The Way of Waterfor Best Cinematography; and Alexandre Desplat, Guillermo Del Toro's Pinocchio for Best Original Score.
The Russell Smith Award, which is given by the DFWFCA for the best low-budget or cutting-edge independent film, was given to EO, a movie about a donkey that wanders around Europe, meeting people and experiencing turns of fortune.
The Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association consists of 26 broadcast, print, and online journalists from throughout North Texas.
There are few directors more adept at moving between genres than Steven Soderbergh. Throughout his career, he has made dramas and comedies, heist films and thrillers, films with serious topics like drug trafficking and films with frivolous subjects like male dancers. He’s also dipped his toe into horror on occasion, something he does again with Presence.
However, typical of the hard-to-pin-down filmmaker, this film is not your typical ghost story, as its plot is told from the perspective of the presence itself. With the camera as its “eyes,” the audience sees a family of four move into an older-but-updated home: Mother Rebekah (Lucy Liu), father Chris (Chris Sullivan), son Tyler (Eddy Maday), and daughter Chloe (Callina Liang). The family dynamics are established early, as Rebekah favors Tyler and pins her hopes and dreams on him, while Chris has a strained relationship with Rebekah and tries to protect Chloe from stress, who has recently gone through a trauma.
The family’s various issues keep the atmosphere tense, and for the most part the presence is merely an observer to their conversations and activities. But Chloe can sense it whenever it’s close to her, and this connection leads it to sometimes announce itself via physical interactions with objects in different rooms. As the other family members gradually become aware of it as well, the story’s supernatural aura starts to increase.
Working from a screenplay by David Koepp, Soderbergh does a kind of switcheroo on audience expectations. In your typical haunted house story, the mystery of the ghost(s) is what drives the plot and keeps things scary. But since the audience, in essence, is the ghost, we know everything it is doing at all times. Instead, the suspense comes from the family itself, who have backstories that make the whole clan dysfunctional, at best.
Story elements are brought in through different ways than your typical film, with little hints being dropped along the way about various things that have happened in the family’s recent past. Why Tyler seems to be angry with Chloe all the time, or why Rebekah and Chris never seem to be on the same page with anything the family is dealing with are equally as interesting as anything the presence is doing.
The first-person perspective (used in a much different way than in the recent - and now Oscar-nominated - Nickel Boys) gives an intimacy to the film that is sometimes invasive, sometimes disorienting, but always engrossing. Soderbergh, who acted as the cameraman himself, takes the camera to almost every nook and cranny of the house, often getting so close to the actors that it’s uncomfortable. The constant, silent movement of the presence/camera makes for great viewing, lending the audience a knowledge they rarely have.
Liu is given a meatier part than she’s had in recent years, and she plays the complicated role for all it’s worth. Sullivan, best known for his role on the NBC TV drama This is Us, is equally good, with a demeanor that’s slightly at odds with his stature, but in a good way. Both Liang and Maday have light resumes (this is Maday’s first credit of any kind), but their performances are what make the film as effective as it is. With the presence more interested in her character than anyone else, Liang is asked to do a lot, and she is especially memorable.
While more of a family drama than a true horror film, the paranormal aspect of Presence gives enough of a spooky vibe for it to qualify. The highly successful film demonstrates that, 36 years after his breakthrough, Soderbergh remains one of the more fascinating directors out there, willing to try different projects instead of doing the same thing over and over again.